Dec 19, 2022 | By JW
I ordered these for my brother who has been living far from Philly for years and certainly would remember the Melrose Diner. He called and said they are the best cookies he's ever tasted! He said he couldn't stop eating them and will be ordering more!
Feb 10, 2022 | By Kat Gregory
I never order cookies, let alone long distance. I originally received these in a gift box at Christmas (thanks to my Cousins). I enjoyed them so much, I ordered more!!
A taste of home
Sep 5, 2021 | By Marsha Per
Had the privilege of growing up within walking distance of Melrose Diner and grew up on their butter cookies. Truly delicious!
Melts in your mouth
Jun 1, 2021 | By Marsha Per
I was born and raised minutes from the Melrose Diner and all their baked goods are top notch. Their butter cookies are incredible and have melt in your mouth goodness! No other cookies can even come close in taste.
Feb 25, 2021 | By Sandy
Melt in your mouth buttery goodness. You can eat these things like potato chips. Only downside is there is not more in the bag.
Feb 25, 2021 | By Nika
Best butter milk cookies that arrived quickly!
May 1, 2020 | By Cathryn Dadamo
We loved all the Philly comfort foods we grew up with!
Melrose Diner Butter Cookies
May 1, 2020 | By SANDRA ANDERSON
Apr 11, 2020 | By Elizabeth Swain
These cookies taste like they just came out of the oven. Very buttery and sweet.
Mar 5, 2020 | By Erik S Wilson
Delicious cookies! Unfortunately they were all broken during shipping. Still tasty though!
Owner Response: Thank you for the feedback. That is a crispy cookie that tends to break. At least I don't stick the whole cookie in my mouth then!
Long distance order review
Nov 25, 2019 | By Cristal Williamson
Quick delivery. Despite cookies arriving pretty crumbled, I was satisfied overall.
Owner Response: Thank you for your review! Melrose diner cookies are a crispy shortbread cookie and they are fragile and experience breaking in shipment. Although I can eat one in one bite-they taste just as good a nibble at a time!
Nov 11, 2017 | By Denise
These yummy buttery cookies remind me of the old fashion Butter Thins, only a tad thicker. You simply cat eat just one!